I know that Squash Pie doesn’t sound as tasty as Pumpkin Pie, but here’s a little known fact: most store-bought pumpkin pies are actually squash pies. The pumpkins we all buy at the grocery store or pumpkin patches make the WORST pumpkin pies ever. Those destined-to-be-decorations are bred for size, not taste.
To reduce the effort and calories, I’ve been making this lately without a crust at all. Baked to perfection, the slices hold up just fine without a crust. Absolutely don’t even think about omitting the whipped cream topping. That would just be wrong.
Here’s my time-tested favorite fall dessert recipe:
Line a pie pan with pie dough. I often cheat and use Trader Joe’s pie dough, which comes frozen. For a while there, they were having a problem with quality control, but the product now is excellent and a big time saver; especially if you don’t make alot of pies and don’t have a system. There was a time when I made a couple pies or quiches a week, and I really had the whole pie dough thing down to a science. Now, not so much and though a Slow Food Advocate, I use Trader’s product.
Preheat oven to 425.
Here’s the recipe:
2 cups of cooked squash or edible pumpkin. Do NOT try using a decorative pumpkin in this recipe. I’ve tried it, and it was awful, just watery and not flavorful at all.
1.5 cups of organic cream. Watch out for the weird stuff grocery stores are now putting in “cream.” Trader Joes is good, and Henry’s and Sprouts have products without the garbage, too.
1/4 cup brown sugar
1/2 cup white sugar
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 Teaspoons Cinnamon
1/2 Teaspoon Ginger
1 Teaspoon Nutmeg or Alspice
1/2 Teaspoon of finely crushed Cloves
2 beaten eggs
Blend it all in a Cuisinart, Vitamix or blender until smooth. Pour mixture into pie shell, bake for 15 minutes at 425, then reduce heat to 350 and bake until a knife inserted in center comes out clean. In my oven, that’s 45 minutes.